Back to Course

Philosophy (Optional) Notes & Mind Maps

0% Complete
0/0 Steps
  1. 1. Plato and Aristotle: Ideas; Substance; Form and Matter; Causation; Actuality and Potentiality

    1.1 Plato's Philosophy of Ideas
  2. 1.2 Plato's Understanding of Substance
  3. 1.3 Aristotle's Philosophy of Form and Matter
  4. 1.4 Aristotle's Theory of Substance
  5. 1.5 Plato's View on Causation
  6. 1.6 Aristotle's Four Causes
  7. 1.7 Actuality and Potentiality in Aristotle's Philosophy
  8. 1.8 Comparative Analysis of Plato and Aristotle's Philosophies
  9. 2. The Foundations of Rationalism: Method, Substance, God, and Mind-Body Dualism
    2.1 Rationalism (Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz)
  10. 2.2 Cartesian Method and Certain Knowledge
  11. 2.3 Substance (Aristotle, Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz)
  12. 2.4 Philosophy of God (Descartes, Spinoza, and Leibniz)
  13. 2.5 Mind-Body Dualism
  14. 2.6 Determinism and Freedom (Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz)
  15. 3. Empiricism (Locke, Berkeley, Hume)
    3.1 Introduction to Empiricism
  16. 3.2 Theory of Knowledge (Locke, Berkeley, Hume)
    3 Submodules
  17. 3.3 Substance and Qualities (Locke, Berkeley, Hume)
  18. 3.4 Self and God (Locke, Berkeley, Hume)
  19. 3.5 Scepticism (Locke, Berkeley, and Hume)
  20. 4. Kant
    4.1 Introduction to Kant's Philosophy
  21. 4.2 Kant: The Possibility of Synthetic a priori Judgments
  22. 4.3 Kant's Space and Time
  23. 4.4 Kant's Categories
  24. 4.5 Kant's Ideas of Reason
  25. 4.6 Kant's Antinomies
  26. 4.7 Kant's Critique of Proofs for the Existence of God
  27. 5. Hegel
    5.1 Hegel: Dialectical Method; Absolute Idealism
  28. 6. Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein
    6.1 Defence of Commonsense (Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein)
  29. 6.2 Refutation of Idealism (Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein)
  30. 6.3 Logical Atomism (Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein)
  31. 6.4 Logical Constructions (Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein)
  32. 6.5 Incomplete Symbols (Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein)
  33. 6.6 Picture Theory of Meaning (Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein)
  34. 6.7 Saying and Showing (Moore, Russell, and Early Wittgenstein)
  35. 7. Logical Positivism
    7.1 Verification Theory of Meaning
  36. 7.2 Rejection of Metaphysics
  37. 7.3 Linguistic Theory of Necessary Propositions
  38. 8. Later Wittgenstein
    8.1 Meaning and Use (Later Wittgenstein)
  39. 8.2 Language-games (Later Wittgenstein)
  40. 8.3 Critique of Private Language (Later Wittgenstein)
  41. 9. Phenomenology (Husserl)
    9.1 Method - Phenomenology (Husserl)
  42. 9.2 Theory of Essences - Phenomenology (Husserl)
  43. 9.3 Avoidance of Psychologism - Phenomenology (Husserl)
  44. 10. Existentialism (Kierkegaard, Sartre, Heidegger)
    10.1 Existence and Essence
  45. 10.2 Choice, Responsibility and Authentic Existence
  46. 10.3 Being–in–the–world and Temporality
  47. 11. Quine and Strawson
    11.1 Critique of Empiricism (Quine and Strawson)
  48. 11.2 Theory of Basic Particulars and Persons (Quine and Strawson)
  49. 12. Cârvâka
    12.1 Cârvâka: Theory of Knowledge
  50. 12.2 Cârvâka: Rejection of Transcendent Entities
  51. 13. Jainism
    13.1 Jainism: Theory of Reality
  52. 13.2 Jainism: Saptabhaòginaya
  53. 14. Schools of Buddhism
    14.1 Pratîtyasamutpâda (Schools of Buddhism)
  54. 14.2 Ksanikavada (Schools of Buddhism)
  55. 14.3 Nairâtmyavâda (Schools of Buddhism)
  56. 15. Nyāya-Vaiśeṣika
    15.1 Theory of Categories (Nyāya-Vaiśeṣika)
  57. 15.2 Theory of Appearance (Nyâya-Vaiśeṣika)
  58. 15.3 Theory of Pramâna (Nyâya-Vaiśeṣika)
  59. 15.4 Self, Liberation, God, Proofs for the Existence of God (Nyâya-Vaiśeṣika)
  60. 15.5 Theory of Causation & Atomistic Theory of Creation (Nyâya-Vaiśeṣika)
  61. 16. Sâmkhya
    16.1 Prakrti (Sâmkhya)
  62. 16.2 Purusa (Sâmkhya)
  63. 16.3 Causation (Sâmkhya)
  64. 16.4 Liberation (Sâmkhya)
  65. 17. Yoga
    17.1 Introduction to Yoga Philosophy
  66. 17.2 Citta (Yoga)
  67. 17.3 Cittavrtti (Yoga)
  68. 17.4 Klesas (Yoga)
  69. 17.5 Samadhi (Yoga)
  70. 17.6 Kaivalya (Yoga)
  71. 18. Mimâmsâ
    18.1 Mimâmsâ: Theory of Knowledge
  72. 19. Schools of Vedânta
    19.1 Brahman (Schools of Vedânta)
  73. 19.2 Îúvara (Schools of Vedânta)
  74. 19.3 Âtman (Schools of Vedânta)
  75. 19.4 Jiva (Schools of Vedânta)
  76. 19.5 Jagat (Schools of Vedânta)
  77. 19.6 Mâyâ (Schools of Vedânta)
  78. 19.7 Avidyâ (Schools of Vedanta)
  79. 19.8 Adhyâsa (Schools of Vedanta)
  80. 19.9 Moksa (Schools of Vedanta)
  81. 19.10 Aprthaksiddhi (Schools of Vedanta)
  82. 19.11 Pancavidhabheda (Schools of Vedanta)
  83. 20.1 Aurobindo: Evolution
  84. 20.2 Aurobindo: Involution
  85. 20.3 Aurobindo: Integral Yoga
  86. 21. Socio-Political Ideals
    21.1 Equality (Social and Political Ideals)
  87. 21.2 Justice (Social and Political Ideals)
  88. 21.3 Liberty (Social and Political Ideals)
  89. 22. Sovereignty
    22. Sovereignty: Austin, Bodin, Laski, Kautilya
  90. 23. Individual and State
    23.1 Rights (Individual and State)
  91. 23.2 Duties (Individual and State)
  92. 23.3 Accountability (Individual and State)
  93. 24. Forms of Government
    24.1 Monarchy (Forms of Government)
  94. 24.2 Theocracy (Forms of Government)
  95. 24.3 Democracy (Forms of Government)
  96. 25. Political Ideologies
    25.1 Anarchism (Political Ideologies)
  97. 25.2 Marxism (Political Ideologies)
  98. 25.3 Socialism (Political Ideologies)
  99. 26. Humanism; Secularism; Multiculturalism
    26.1 Humanism
  100. 26.2 Secularism
  101. 26.3 Multiculturalism
  102. 27. Crime and Punishment
    27.1 Corruption
  103. 27.2 Mass Violence
  104. 27.3 Genocide
  105. 27.4 Capital Punishment
  106. 28. Development and Social Progress
    28. Development and Social Progress
  107. 29. Gender Discrimination
    29.1 Female Foeticide
  108. 29.2 Land, and Property Rights
  109. 29.3 Empowerment
  110. 30. Caste Discrimination
    30.1 Gandhi (Caste Discrimination)
  111. 30.2 Ambedkar (Caste Discrimination)
  112. Philosophy of Religion
    31. Notions of God: Attributes; Relation to Man and the World (Indian and Western)
  113. 32. Proofs for the Existence of God and their Critique (Indian and Western)
  114. 33. The problem of Evil
  115. 34. Soul: Immortality; Rebirth and Liberation
  116. 35. Reason, Revelation, and Faith
  117. 36. Religious Experience: Nature and Object (Indian and Western)
  118. 37. Religion without God
  119. 38. Religion and Morality
  120. 39. Religious Pluralism and the Problem of Absolute Truth
  121. 40. Nature of Religious Language: Analogical and Symbolic
  122. 41. Nature of Religious Language: Cognitivist and Noncognitive
Module 68 of 122
In Progress

17.4 Klesas (Yoga)

I. Introduction to Klesas

Defining Klesas within the Context of Yoga Philosophy

  • Klesas, a term from ancient Indian yogic scriptures, primarily denotes the mental afflictions that act as impediments on the spiritual journey.
  • Rooted in Sanskrit, the word ‘Klesa’ translates to ‘pain’ or ‘suffering’, hinting at the challenges faced during spiritual practices.
  • Yoga, often perceived as just a physical discipline, is also a profound philosophical journey, where understanding the mind’s intricacies becomes pivotal. In this context, Klesas are significant hurdles that yogis need to overcome.
  • Within yoga philosophy, Klesas are intimately tied to the process of self-realization. They are the barriers that cloud pure consciousness and distance an individual from achieving their highest potential.

The Relationship between Klesas, Suffering, and Spiritual Development

  • All human experiences, especially suffering, are closely tied to the Klesas. For instance, Avidya (ignorance) can lead to misconceptions, leading to suffering.
  • When one starts on the path of spiritual development, recognizing these afflictions becomes the first step. It’s akin to diagnosing an ailment before prescribing a remedy.
  • Spiritual growth in yoga doesn’t merely imply the attainment of higher states of consciousness like Samadhi but also involves the eradication or diminution of these Klesas.
  • Often, yogic practitioners undergo challenges that bring these afflictions to the surface. Through practices like meditation, asanas, and self-reflection, they gradually reduce the grip of these Klesas, making way for a clearer perception of reality.
  • It’s important to note that the process is cyclical. With each level of spiritual attainment, new facets of Klesas might appear, demanding further introspection and refinement.

How Klesas Relate to Citta and Cittavrtti without Delving into the Specifics

  • The term Citta in yogic philosophy refers to the ‘mind-stuff’ or the combination of mind, intellect, and ego. It’s the canvas on which thoughts, feelings, and experiences are painted.
  • Cittavrtti, on the other hand, denotes the ‘modifications’ or ‘turbulence’ in the Citta. These are the ripples of thoughts and feelings that continuously arise in our minds.
  • Klesas, being mental afflictions, are closely tied to the functioning of the Citta. They can be perceived as the deeply embedded stains or impressions in the Citta that give rise to recurrent patterns of Cittavrtti.
  • A person dominated by Raga (attachment) will have Cittavrttis inclined towards desires and cravings, while someone overwhelmed by Dvesha (aversion) might consistently have thoughts of aversion or resentment.
  • The central aim of many yogic practices is to calm the Cittavrttis and cleanse the Citta of these Klesas. By reducing the impact of Klesas, the Citta becomes more transparent, facilitating a more profound insight into one’s true nature.
  • To draw an analogy, if Citta were water in a pond, Cittavrttis would be the ripples on it, and Klesas, the mud settled at the bottom. While the ripples might disturb the water’s surface momentarily, the mud, when agitated, can cloud the entire pond. Yogic practices aim to both calm the ripples and gradually remove the mud, ensuring a clear, placid pond.

II. Historical Development of the Concept

Origins and Evolutions of Klesas in Ancient Yogic Texts

  • Klesas find their foundational roots in ancient Indian scriptures, particularly in the core yogic texts. These are fundamental to understanding the mental barriers faced in spiritual practices.
  • The concept of Klesas has been extensively discussed in the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, a seminal text in the realm of yoga. Here, Patanjali identifies five primary Klesas: Avidya (ignorance), Asmita (ego), Raga (attachment), Dvesha (aversion), and Abhinivesha (fear of death).
  • Mahabharata and Bhagavad Gita also touch upon similar themes, emphasizing the human tendencies that hinder spiritual growth.
  • Over time, as the interpretations of these scriptures evolved, so did the understanding of Klesas. Different commentators, like Vyasa, expanded upon Patanjali’s concepts, providing deeper insights into the nature of these afflictions.
  • Ancient schools like Samkhya delved deeper into the psyche’s composition, offering a granular view on how Klesas arise and persist. This school posited that understanding the balance between Purusha (consciousness) and Prakriti (material nature) is key to navigating Klesas.

Comparative Analysis of Klesas in Different Yoga Traditions and Schools

  • Classical Yoga: Rooted in the teachings of Patanjali, this tradition focuses primarily on the eightfold path (Ashtanga). Klesas are seen as disturbances that need rectification for spiritual ascension. Addressing them directly aids in achieving the tranquillity of mind and spirit.
  • Bhakti Yoga: Known as the path of devotion, Bhakti Yoga interprets Klesas as emotional barriers. By channeling devotion towards a higher power, the practitioner can overcome these obstacles. Klesas are transformed into positive emotions, channeling love and surrender.
  • Jnana Yoga: This path of knowledge and wisdom views Klesas as misconceptions of reality. By gaining true knowledge, one dispels ignorance (Avidya), the root of all Klesas. It is believed that right understanding eradicates Klesas.
  • Karma Yoga: The yoga of selfless action perceives Klesas as outcomes of attachment to results. By acting without expecting rewards, one can negate the influence of Klesas. Here, detachment is the key to overcoming these afflictions.
  • Tantric Yoga: This esoteric branch sees Klesas as energy blockages. Utilizing specific rituals and practices, the energy is redirected to balance and harmonize the chakras, addressing Klesas at an energetic level.
  • Hatha Yoga: A physically oriented practice that incorporates postures and breathing techniques. Klesas are viewed as imbalances in the physical and subtle body. By mastering postures and pranayama, one can release these blockages, paving the path to spiritual progression.
  • Schools like Advaita Vedanta perceive Klesas from a non-dual perspective. Here, the focus is on realizing the oneness of existence. Once this realization dawns, Klesas lose their grip, as the dualities that fuel them dissolve.

III. The Five Klesas: An In-depth Study

5 Klesas

Avidya (Ignorance) as the Root Klesa

  • Avidya stands for ignorance or misunderstanding in Sanskrit.
  • It is perceived as the foundational Klesa from which all other Klesas emerge.
  • Avidya can be understood as the misapprehension of the true nature of reality.
    • Seeing the impermanent as permanent.
    • Misidentifying the non-self (Anatman) as the self (Atman).
    • Viewing suffering as happiness and vice versa.
  • From the yogic perspective, dispelling Avidya paves the way to spiritual enlightenment.
  • Examples: The Indian concept of Maya, which denotes illusion, mirrors Avidya. The world, with its ever-changing nature, might deceive one into perceiving it as real and unchanging.

Asmita (Egoism) and Its Influence on Perception

  • Asmita translates to ego or I-am-ness.
  • It’s the false identification of the self with the body, mind, or emotions.
  • Asmita makes individuals perceive themselves as separate entities, distinct from the broader universe.
    • This results in feelings of pride, arrogance, or inferiority.
  • When people are driven by ego, their decisions are often misguided, as they prioritize their limited self over the collective good.
  • In Indian society, the story of King Harishchandra exemplifies the taming of the ego. Despite being a noble king, he undergoes severe trials, displaying humility and egolessness.

Raga (Attachment) and Its Impact on Mental State

  • Raga signifies attachment or desire.
  • It’s the yearning for pleasurable experiences or objects.
  • Excessive attachment might lead to suffering when the desired object or experience is lost or remains unattained.
    • For instance, attachment to material wealth can result in fear of loss, leading to stress or anxiety.
  • From the yogic viewpoint, it’s essential to cultivate non-attachment or Vairagya to achieve inner peace.
  • The Indian festival of Diwali, marking Lord Rama’s return, subtly underscores moving beyond material attachments, emphasizing the inner light of wisdom and consciousness.

Dvesha (Aversion) and Its Psychological Manifestations

  • Dvesha is aversion or repulsion towards unpleasant experiences or objects.
  • Opposite to Raga, it’s the resistance or avoidance of what one perceives as negative.
  • Such aversions can limit one’s experiences and potential, fostering close-mindedness.
    • For example, a traumatic experience might make an individual avoid similar situations, even if they’re benign.
  • Overcoming Dvesha involves embracing every experience as an opportunity for growth.
  • The Indian parable of the poisoned arrow, often associated with Buddhist teachings, highlights the impracticality of aversion. Instead of avoiding or overanalyzing, it advocates for addressing the root cause directly.

Abhinivesha (Fear of Death) and Its Universality

  • Abhinivesha denotes the deep-seated fear of death or clinging to life.
  • Even knowledgeable individuals, who might intellectually grasp the impermanence of life, can be gripped by this fear.
  • This fear can hinder spiritual growth, as it keeps individuals rooted in the physical realm, away from transcendent experiences.
    • For instance, someone might avoid certain activities or experiences due to the irrational fear of harm or death.
  • Yogic practices aim at confronting and understanding this fear to move beyond it.
  • The Indian epic, the Mahabharata, particularly the dialogue between Yudhishthira and Yaksha, delves into the human inability to grasp the inevitability of death, even when it’s evident everywhere.
KlesaDescriptionCore IssueManifestation in Daily Life
AvidyaIgnorance of one’s true self and realityLack of true knowledge or spiritual blindnessMisunderstanding situations, misjudging people, confusion
AsmitaEgoism, identification of the self with the physical bodyFalse sense of individuality and separationPride, arrogance, excessive self-centeredness
RagaAttachment or desire for pleasurable experiencesSeeking happiness externallyGreed, uncontrolled desires, addiction
DveshaAversion or avoidance of unpleasant experiencesResisting or denying certain aspects of realityHatred, prejudice, anger, resentment
AbhiniveshaFear of death or clinging to life despite its painsDeep-seated survival instinct regardless of wisdomAnxiety about aging, fear of unknown, reluctance to change

IV. Interplay of Klesas and the Path to Samadhi and Kaivalya

Klesas as Barriers to Higher Spiritual States

  • Understanding Klesas: They are obstacles or afflictions that veil one’s true nature.
  • Klesas cloud the spiritual aspirant’s awareness, obscuring the path to enlightenment.
  • They distort perceptions, leading to misjudgments and fostering a state of spiritual delusion.
  • Binding individuals to the material world, they hinder progress on the spiritual journey.
  • Role in Samsara: Klesas contribute to the cycle of birth, death, and rebirth, keeping the soul trapped in the world of illusions.

Analyzing Methods Yogis Employ to Overcome or Diminish These Barriers

  • Sadhana (Spiritual Practices): Rigorous discipline and practices to purify the mind and body.
    • For instance, the Eight Limbs of Yoga (Ashtanga Yoga) by Patanjali.
  • Svadhyaya (Self-study): Introspection and reflection on one’s thoughts and actions.
  • Tapas (Austerity): Physical and mental discipline to cultivate inner strength.
    • Fasting during the month of Shravan in the Indian calendar is an example.
  • Pratyahara (Withdrawal from the Senses): Redirecting attention from external stimuli to the internal self.
  • Dhyana (Meditation): Focused concentration to overcome the fluctuations of the mind.
    • Techniques such as “Trataka” where one gazes at a single point, like a candle flame, to develop concentration.
  • Satsang (Company of the Truthful): Associating with enlightened beings or seekers to gain wisdom and motivation.

Understanding the Influence of Klesas on Samadhi and Kaivalya

  • Samadhi: It is a state of superconsciousness where the individual self merges with the universal consciousness.
    • Klesas can prevent a person from reaching this state by tethering the mind to material and ephemeral desires.
    • Overcoming Klesas enables the Yogi to access deeper states of meditation, eventually leading to Samadhi.
    • A prominent Indian example is the life of Swami Vivekananda, whose meditative practices led him to profound states of Samadhi, despite life’s challenges.
  • Kaivalya: Often termed as “absolute freedom” or “spiritual liberation”.
    • It’s the state where the soul realizes its true, independent nature, free from the shackles of the material world.
    • Klesas, if not addressed, make this liberation elusive. They shroud the soul in ignorance, leading it astray from the path of self-realization.
    • The story of King Janaka, who, despite being a monarch with vast wealth and responsibilities, attained Kaivalya due to his detached and enlightened perspective, illustrates the achievable balance between worldly duties and spiritual pursuits.

The Journey Beyond Klesas

  • Recognizing the nature and influence of Klesas is the first step in a Yogi’s journey towards self-realization.
  • The objective isn’t just to suppress or avoid Klesas, but to understand, confront, and transcend them.
  • As Klesas diminish, the aspirant’s inner light shines brighter, illuminating the path to higher states of consciousness.
  • Thus, mastering the Klesas doesn’t just serve personal spiritual growth but also benefits society by creating wise and compassionate individuals.
  • Indian seers and sages, through ages, have emphasized the importance of overcoming Klesas to attain a state of inner peace and true freedom.

V. Comparative Study: Klesas in Other Philosophical Systems

Introduction to Similar Concepts in Other Eastern Philosophies

  • Buddhism:
    • Rooted in India, founded by Siddhartha Gautama, known as the Buddha.
    • Discusses the Three Poisons:
      • Ignorance (Avidya): Corresponds with the Klesa concept in Yoga.
      • Desire: Similar to Raga (attachment).
      • Aversion: Relates to Dvesha (aversion).
    • The Noble Eightfold Path: Offers a way to overcome these hindrances.
  • Jainism:
    • Originated in India around the same time as Buddhism.
    • Emphasizes non-attachment and non-violence.
    • Karmic matter: Clings to the soul due to passions, comparable to the Klesas.
    • Anekantavada: Doctrine suggesting multiplicity of perspectives; highlights how ignorance (Avidya) can lead to one-sided views.
  • Taoism:
    • Ancient Chinese philosophy introduced by Laozi.
    • Wu Wei: “Non-action” or “effortless action”, implies detachment, resonating with the idea of avoiding Raga (attachment) and Dvesha (aversion).
    • Yin and Yang: Balance of opposing forces; correlates with overcoming Klesas to achieve equilibrium.

Analyzing Differences and Similarities with Concepts in Western Philosophical Systems

  • Greek Philosophy:
    • Epicureanism:
      • Founded by Epicurus in Athens, Greece.
      • Pursuit of ataraxia (tranquility) and hedone (pleasure) by avoiding physical and mental pain.
      • These desires can be likened to Raga (attachment) and avoiding pain correlates with Dvesha (aversion).
    • Stoicism:
      • Introduced by Zeno of Citium.
      • Central tenet: Accepting things we can’t change and distinguishing between what we can and cannot control.
      • Relates to overcoming Avidya (ignorance) and Asmita (egoism) by recognizing one’s limits.
  • Modern Western Philosophy:
    • Existentialism:
      • Prominent figures include Jean-Paul Sartre and Friedrich Nietzsche.
      • Addresses the individual’s quest for authenticity and self-discovery.
      • Concepts of “bad faith” and “authentic existence” mirror the struggle against Avidya (ignorance) and Asmita (egoism).
    • Utilitarianism:
      • Founded by Jeremy Bentham and further developed by John Stuart Mill.
      • Principle of the “greatest good for the greatest number”.
      • Evaluates the utility of actions based on their outcomes.
      • The pursuit of pleasure and avoidance of pain in this system can be equated with Raga (attachment) and Dvesha (aversion).
  • Psychoanalytical Theory:
    • Sigmund Freud’s Model:
      • Discussed the conflict between the Id (primitive desires), Ego (reality), and Superego (morality).
      • The Id’s desires can parallel Raga (attachment), while the restrictions of the Superego might be seen as a form of Dvesha (aversion).
      • The Ego’s balancing act resembles the yogic pursuit of equilibrium amidst the Klesas.
    • Carl Jung’s Theory:
      • Introduced the concept of the “Shadow”, the unconscious part of personality containing repressed weaknesses.
      • Addressing and integrating the Shadow can be compared to confronting and transcending the Klesas.
ConceptYoga (Klesas)Eastern PhilosophiesWestern Philosophies
IgnoranceAvidya: Ignorance of true self and realityBuddhism: Avidya (Ignorance)Plato’s Allegory of the Cave: Ignorance of the true world
EgoismAsmita: Identification with the physical bodyTaoism: Wu Wei (Non-action, without ego-driven motive)Cartesian Dualism: Distinctness of mind and body
DesireRaga: Attachment to pleasurable experiencesBuddhism: Tanha (Thirst or craving)Hedonism: Pursuit of pleasure and intrinsic goods
AversionDvesha: Aversion to unpleasant experiencesBuddhism: Dukkha (Suffering due to attachment/aversion)Stoicism: Indifference to pain or pleasure
Fear of DeathAbhinivesha: Clinging to life despite its painsConfucianism: Focus on virtuous life over afterlifeExistentialism: Fear of the meaningless and transient nature of life

VI. Klesas and Modern Psychology

Investigating parallels between Klesas and psychological concepts

  • Historical origins:
    • Klesas, rooted in ancient Indian philosophical systems, primarily Yoga and Buddhism, denote mental afflictions.
    • Modern psychology, originating in the late 19th century, provides a systematic study of behavior and mind.
  • Comparison between Avidya (ignorance) and cognitive biases:
    • Avidya is the fundamental Klesa, causing misperception of reality.
    • Cognitive biases, identified in psychology, distort an individual’s perception, leading to inaccurate judgments.
  • Raga (attachment) and the pleasure principle:
    • Raga signifies excessive attachment to pleasurable experiences.
    • Sigmund Freud’s pleasure principle posits that individuals seek pleasure and avoid pain, reflecting similar underlying motives.
  • Dvesha (aversion) in correlation with avoidance behaviors:
    • Dvesha denotes repulsion or aversion towards unpleasant experiences.
    • Avoidance behaviors, recognized in behavioral psychology, describe actions taken to escape distressing situations, mirroring the concept of Dvesha.
  • Asmita (ego) and self-concept:
    • Asmita signifies a distorted sense of self or ego.
    • In psychology, the self-concept relates to one’s perception of self, incorporating self-esteem and self-image. The erroneous self-concept can mirror the distortions of Asmita.
  • Abhinivesha (fear of death) and existential anxieties:
    • Abhinivesha is the deep-rooted fear of death and the clinging to life.
    • Existential psychology explores inherent human anxieties, particularly death anxiety, mirroring the concerns of Abhinivesha.

Arguing for or against the universality of the Klesas in the human psyche

  • In favor of universality:
    • Ubiquitous presence: Klesas, as ancient concepts, are evident in varied cultures, suggesting a universal human experience.
    • Underlying human behavior: Modern psychological principles, spanning diverse cultures, echo Klesa concepts, implying universality.
  • Arguments against universality:
    • Cultural specificity: While Klesas originate from Indian philosophical systems, not every culture or psychological school may recognize or prioritize these exact afflictions.
    • Evolution of thought: Modern society, with its unique challenges and contexts, might not resonate entirely with ancient Klesa descriptions.

Critiquing the potential of applying Klesa theory in modern therapeutic contexts

  • Advantages of Klesa integration:
    • Holistic approach: Incorporating Klesas offers a comprehensive perspective, merging cognitive, emotional, and spiritual dimensions.
    • Root cause analysis: By addressing Klesas, therapists can tackle foundational issues instead of mere symptomatic relief.
    • Enhancing self-awareness: Recognizing and understanding Klesas can promote self-awareness, a vital component in therapeutic healing.
  • Challenges in Klesa integration:
    • Cultural competence: Therapists need a deep understanding of Klesa concepts and cultural nuances to apply them effectively.
    • Resistance to non-Western concepts: Some individuals might be skeptical of non-Western ideas, hindering their acceptance in therapy.
  • Potential areas of application:
    • Mindfulness and meditation: Therapies like Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) could benefit from Klesa insights, deepening the therapeutic process.
    • Integrative therapy: Therapists can design integrative approaches, merging Klesa concepts with existing therapeutic modalities for enhanced outcomes.
    • Group therapy: Discussing Klesas in group settings can foster collective understanding and support in addressing these afflictions.
KlesasDescription in YogaEquivalent/Similar Concepts in Modern Psychology
AvidyaIgnorance of true self and realityCognitive Dissonance: Holding contradictory beliefs, values, or attitudes
AsmitaEgoism or identification with the physical bodyEgo Identity: One’s sense of self based on personal experiences and external feedback
RagaAttachment to pleasurable experiencesPositive Reinforcement: Strengthening behavior by presenting a desirable stimulus
DveshaAversion to unpleasant experiencesNegative Reinforcement: Strengthening behavior by removing an aversive stimulus
AbhiniveshaDeep-seated fear of death and clinging to lifeThanatophobia: Extreme fear of death or the process of dying; Existential Anxiety: Fear stemming from life’s inherent meaninglessness

VII. Practical Applications: Overcoming Klesas in Daily Life

Analyzing methods ancient yogis prescribed for diminishing Klesas

  • Origins in Yoga Sutras: The Yoga Sutras, an ancient text authored by Patanjali, provides a comprehensive outline of the path to spiritual enlightenment. Within this text, solutions to Klesas are explored.
  • Yama and Niyama: These are the initial two limbs of the eightfold path of yoga. They deal with ethical standards and personal conduct, respectively.
    • Ahimsa: Non-violence towards oneself and others. By practicing non-violence, one reduces Dvesha or aversion.
    • Satya: Truthfulness, which battles Avidya or ignorance.
    • Brahmacharya: Moderation in sensory experiences, countering Raga or attachment.
    • Santosha: Cultivating contentment and reducing Asmita, or ego.
  • Asana and Pranayama: Physical postures and breath control practices aimed to stabilize and purify the body and mind.
    • Directly confronts Abhinivesha, the fear of death or clinging to life, by instilling physical and mental discipline.
  • Pratyahara: Withdrawal of senses from external objects.
    • Helps in detachment, addressing both Raga (attachment) and Dvesha (aversion).
  • Dharana, Dhyana, and Samadhi: Concentration, meditation, and union with the divine.
    • Direct practices to combat all Klesas, especially Avidya, by promoting clarity and union with universal truth.

Contemporary methods and practices that are informed by ancient wisdom

  • Mindfulness and Meditation: Modern adaptations of Dhyana.
    • Encourages present-moment awareness, reducing the effects of Avidya.
    • Used widely in clinical settings for mental well-being.
  • Breathwork and Biofeedback: Modern interpretations of Pranayama.
    • Helps individuals gain control over physiological functions, battling Abhinivesha.
  • Lifestyle and Diet Choices: Drawing from Yama and Niyama.
    • Vegetarianism, akin to Ahimsa, promoting non-violence.
    • Fasting and Ayurvedic diets, derived from ancient Indian practices, promoting balance.
  • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT):
    • Though not directly derived from ancient wisdom, CBT’s principles align with addressing Avidya by rectifying cognitive distortions.
  • Group Therapy and Communal Practices:
    • Resonates with Sangha or community’s importance in ancient traditions.
    • Facilitates shared understanding and collective combat against Klesas.

Criticism and analysis of the effectiveness of such methods in today’s world

  • Changing Societal Dynamics:
    • Earlier, communities were smaller, and ancient practices were community-centric. In the urban sprawl, individual-focused practices may be more challenging.
    • The fast-paced nature of today’s world might make prolonged meditation and introspection seem inaccessible to many.
  • Commercialization of Ancient Practices:
    • Yoga, once a spiritual practice, is sometimes criticized for its commercial transformation, potentially diluting its efficacy against Klesas.
  • Overemphasis on Physical Aspects:
    • Modern adaptations often emphasize the physical benefits, like flexibility or strength, over spiritual growth, potentially limiting their effectiveness against Klesas.
  • Science and Spirituality:
    • Some critics argue that without empirical evidence, relying on spiritual practices might be outdated. However, numerous studies now back the benefits of meditation, yoga, and other practices.
  • Cultural Appropriation:
    • As Eastern practices become global, there’s criticism around understanding and respecting their origins, potentially impacting their effectiveness.
  • Effectiveness in Mental Health:
    • While ancient practices offer tools to combat Klesas, they should complement, not replace, modern mental health treatments when needed.

VIII. Debates and Controversies Surrounding Klesas

Highlighting key scholarly arguments about the interpretation of Klesas

  • Origins and Evolution
    • Klesas, having deep roots in the Yoga Sutras, also find mentions in various other ancient texts like the Upanishads.
    • Different eras and regions led to variations in interpretations and practices related to Klesas.
    • For instance, while early texts emphasized the spiritual aspects, later texts may have stressed more on the practical applications or intertwined them with local customs and traditions.
  • Variations in Number and Names
    • Some traditions reference five main Klesas, while others might mention more or fewer.
    • Names of certain Klesas differ across regions and languages, leading to potential overlaps or distinctions in their meanings.
  • Interactions with Other Philosophical Constructs
    • Buddhism, another ancient Indian philosophy, discusses similar concepts with slight variations in interpretation.
    • Debates have arisen regarding whether Klesas in Yogic traditions were influenced by or influenced the Buddhist view on similar afflictions.
  • Metaphorical vs. Literal Interpretations
    • Scholars argue over whether the descriptions of Klesas are metaphors for broader psychological constructs or should be taken at face value.
    • For instance, Avidya, which means ‘ignorance’, is it just the lack of knowledge, or a more profound ignorance about the true nature of reality?
  • Relevance in Modern Context
    • The dynamic nature of human psychology and evolving societal norms raise questions about the applicability of Klesas in the modern world.
    • Some argue that the core nature of Klesas remains unchanged across eras, while others believe they need reinterpretation to fit contemporary life.

Criticizing the potential oversimplification or over-complication of Klesas in various texts and traditions

  • Modern Adaptations and Misinterpretations
    • With the global spread of yoga and Eastern philosophies, Klesas have been introduced to diverse cultures, often leading to diluted or overly simplified versions.
    • Self-help books, online courses, or short-duration workshops sometimes offer quick fixes for overcoming Klesas, which may not capture their depth or essence.
  • Over-complication in Scholarly Discussions
    • In contrast to oversimplification, some academic discourses delve so deep into the intricacies that the core essence becomes hard to grasp for laypersons.
    • Arguments on minute details of interpretation, while academically enriching, can sometimes detract from the broader applicability and understanding of Klesas.
  • Tradition-specific Rigid Interpretations
    • Certain traditions or schools of thought hold rigid views about Klesas, not accommodating evolving interpretations or cross-cultural influences.
    • This rigidity can limit the broader understanding and applicability of Klesas in diverse contexts.
  • Commercialization and Cultural Appropriation
    • The rise in popularity of Eastern philosophies in the West has led to the commercialization of concepts, including Klesas.
    • This often results in a mix of cultures, where Klesas are blended with Western psychology or self-help techniques, leading to potential misinterpretations or oversimplifications.
  • Comparisons with Modern Psychological Constructs
    • Modern psychology, with its vast research and empirical data, offers concepts that might seem to overlap with Klesas.
    • The debate arises whether Klesas are just ancient representations of modern psychological constructs or hold unique insights not captured by contemporary psychology.
  • Indian Context and Global Interpretations
    • Klesas, having roots in ancient Indian philosophy, have cultural, social, and historical contexts that might be overlooked when interpreted globally.
    • Some believe that without understanding these nuances, global interpretations can either oversimplify or over-complicate Klesas.

IX. Future Perspectives on Klesas

Predicting how the concept of Klesas might evolve with growing global interest in yoga and Eastern philosophies

  • Growth of Yoga Worldwide
    • Yoga has transcended from its Indian origins and is now practiced globally.
    • Along with physical postures, the philosophical teachings are also gaining traction.
    • The International Day of Yoga, endorsed by the United Nations, is a testament to its growing popularity.
  • Integration in Global Health and Well-being Approaches
    • Yoga and meditation are increasingly being integrated into mainstream health and well-being practices.
    • Klesas, as core hindrances in human development, will likely be explored in psychotherapy and counseling.
  • Modern Interpretations of Klesas
    • As yoga spreads, the interpretation of Klesas will adapt to fit various cultural contexts.
    • The core principles may remain, but the approach to overcoming these obstacles may differ.
  • Influence on Education and Corporate Sectors
    • Concepts like mindfulness, stemming from Eastern philosophies, have entered educational curricula and corporate wellness programs.
    • With Klesas representing mental blocks, there’s potential for these concepts to be integrated into stress management and personal development modules.
  • Digital Age and Klesas
    • The digital age, marked by the rise of social media and online communities, offers platforms for discussing and disseminating knowledge about Klesas.
    • Apps, online courses, and virtual seminars could be instrumental in shaping the next generation’s understanding of Klesas.
  • Potential Misinterpretations and Commercialization
    • With the globalization of yoga, there’s a risk of misinterpreting or oversimplifying Klesas.
    • Commercial entities might package Klesas-related teachings into marketable products, potentially diluting the essence.

Arguing for the continued relevance or irrelevance of Klesas in modern spiritual pursuits

  • Relevance of Klesas
    • Timeless Nature of Human Struggles
      • Despite technological and societal advances, humans still grapple with the same fundamental internal struggles.
      • Avidya (ignorance) or Raga (attachment) are universal and timeless issues, as relevant today as they were millennia ago.
    • Rise in Mental Health Issues
      • With increasing reports of mental health issues worldwide, understanding and addressing the root causes, potentially linked to Klesas, becomes crucial.
    • Need for Holistic Well-being
      • The pursuit of well-being has shifted from just physical health to a more holistic approach, encompassing mental and spiritual health. Klesas, as impediments to spiritual growth, thus remain pertinent.
    • Increased Interest in Spirituality
      • A growing segment of the population, disillusioned with material pursuits, is turning to spirituality. In such scenarios, understanding Klesas becomes essential to navigate the spiritual path.
  • Arguments for Irrelevance of Klesas
    • Changing Nature of Societal Challenges
      • Modern society faces unique challenges, such as digital addiction or information overload. Traditional concepts of Klesas might not fully address these.
    • Shifts in Spiritual Paradigms
      • As spirituality evolves, new paradigms emerge which might not necessarily align with the concept of Klesas.
    • Potential for Dogma
      • If Klesas are followed rigidly without adapting to the times, they risk becoming dogmatic beliefs rather than useful tools for self-improvement.
    • Diverse Spiritual Avenues
      • The modern spiritual seeker has a plethora of avenues and practices to explore, from Sufism to Taoism. In such a vast landscape, Klesas might lose their prominence.

X. Conclusion and Reflections on Klesas

Significance of Klesas in Yoga’s Study

  • At the core of yoga lies the deep understanding of the human psyche.
  • Klesas offer insight into internal struggles and impediments.
  • Delving into Klesas provides a roadmap to self-awareness.
  • By understanding afflictions, yoga practitioners can cultivate strategies to navigate them.
  • Yoga’s essence extends beyond physical postures; understanding Klesas integrates the philosophical and mental facets.
  • Drawing from ancient texts like the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, Klesas hold a prime place in understanding the journey towards self-realization.
  • The connection between external behavior and internal afflictions becomes more evident when one grasps the Klesas’ nuances.

Critical Examination of Klesas’ Adaptability

  • Traditions evolve and adapt over time. Thus, interpretations of Klesas have witnessed shifts over centuries.
  • Klesas’ foundational philosophy remains consistent, but the lens through which it’s viewed has diversified.
  • Contemporary society faces challenges distinct from ancient times, like technological addictions or information overload. Adapting Klesas to address such modern afflictions requires thoughtful examination.
  • For instance, Avidya (ignorance) can now be seen in the context of misinformation in the digital age.
  • The strength of Klesas lies in their adaptability; their essence can be molded to address issues across epochs.

Applicability in Diverse Cultural Contexts

  • Klesas, originating from Indian philosophical thought, have found resonance in diverse global contexts.
  • Their universal nature transcends geographical and cultural boundaries.
  • Various cultures have found alignments with their own spiritual and philosophical teachings.
  • In Japan, for instance, the concept of Mujō (impermanence) aligns closely with Anitya, one of the characteristics of worldly existence leading to Klesas.
  • Similarly, Western psychotherapy has parallels in understanding human afflictions, where Klesas can offer an enriched perspective.
  • However, care must be taken to respect cultural nuances and avoid oversimplification.

Final Thoughts on the Journey Through Klesas

  • Yoga is more than a physical discipline; it’s a voyage of self-discovery.
  • Klesas act as markers on this journey, highlighting areas of growth and introspection.
  • Their relevance, though ancient, remains poignant in the modern era.
  • Each Klesa offers a mirror, reflecting aspects of our being that might need attention.
  • It’s essential to approach them not as rigid constructs but as fluid concepts adaptable to personal contexts.
  • Whether one is a seasoned yogi in the Himalayas or a beginner in a bustling city, the lessons from Klesas hold profound value.
  • As we conclude this exploration, the invitation is to continue pondering, questioning, and internalizing the wisdom Klesas offer, integrating them into one’s personal and collective journey.
  1. Elucidate on the primary Klesas as defined in Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras and explain their relevance in the contemporary world. How has the growing global interest in yoga influenced the understanding of these Klesas? (250 words)
  2. How does the study of Klesas enhance the comprehension of yoga beyond its physical postures? Discuss the implications of this philosophical understanding on human psyche and behavior. (250 words)
  3. Analyze the adaptability of Klesas in addressing both ancient and modern challenges, especially in diverse cultural contexts. Provide examples to highlight the universality of these afflictions. (250 words)


Home Courses Plans Account