[Paper 1] Political Theory: Meaning & Approaches

Introduction

Political theory forms the foundation of understanding how societies are governed, how power operates, and how political institutions function. It explores questions related to the state, government, laws, liberty, and justice. This article explains the meaning, significance, and approaches of political theory using the full scope provided in the mindmap. It touches on basic concepts like society, state, and politics, and extends into the nature and types of political theory with traditional and modern approaches. Through this exploration, one gains clarity about the theoretical framework and real-world applications of political life.

Some Basic Concepts

• Society: Defined as a group of individuals living together to satisfy their mutual needs. It is the most basic unit where human interaction and organization begin.
• State:
  • A society that is politically organized under common laws within set boundaries.
  • The state ensures protection of life, liberty, and property.
  • It promotes human welfare and a good life.
• Government:
  • The agent of the state through which its will is formulated, expressed, and realized.
  • It consists of institutions responsible for making collective decisions for the society.
• Politics:
  • Refers to the study of the state and government activities.
  • Involves current state and government issues as well as co-operation, conflict, and competition in society.
• Science:
  • A systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world.
• Theory:
  • Refers to results of thoughts and research.
• Political Science:
  • A branch of knowledge that systematically studies the structure and behavior of the state and political institutions.
  • Thinkers like Gettle, Aristotle, and Garner defined it as the science of the state or polis.
  • An academic and social science discipline dealing with political behavior, institutions, and systems.
  • Includes the study of government, political parties, pressure groups, and power dynamics.
  • Helps people understand their political rights and responsibilities, form public opinion, and analyze political trends and problems.
  • Political science uses scientific methods like observation, generalization, explanation, prediction, and prescription.
  • Its scope includes the relationship between man and state, international relations, political theory, law, and historical development of political institutions.

Concept of Political Theory: Meaning

• Political theory is a subfield of political science that studies fundamental political questions such as the state, government, politics, liberty, justice, and law.
• It is built on thought and research of political scholars and deals with political concepts developed by theorists.
• It attempts to describe, explain, and predict political events and behavior.
• Definitions by thinkers:
  • Germino: Political theory is a tradition that critically views society and transcends immediate practical concerns.
  • Sabine: It is man’s effort to understand and solve group life problems and alter practices through investigation.

Scope of Political Theory

• Concerned with three types of statements:
  • Empirical statements: Based on observation and sense-experience.
  • Logical statements: Based on reasoning (e.g., “two plus two is four”).
  • Evaluative statements: Based on value judgments (e.g., “men are born free and equal”).
• Critics like logical positivists argue evaluative statements lack empirical and logical value, but political theory must deal with values and philosophy, not just scientific data.
• Political theory helps in understanding political behaviors, linking the political with non-political, and integrating knowledge from various social sciences.

Contents of Political Theory

• It focuses on understanding what is truly ‘political’, distinguishing it from the non-political, and integrating findings from other social sciences to deepen this understanding.
• As per Sheldon Wolin (Politics and Vision, 1960), political theory:
  • Involves activities aimed at competitive advantage among groups, individuals, and societies.
  • Takes place in contexts of change and scarcity, which make the outcomes impactful for the entire society or a large segment of it.
  • Studies consequences of political actions that influence social structures and societal well-being.
• Its scope reaches beyond what is directly political, including peripheral and surrounding elements of political life.

Implications of Political Theory

• Political theory covers the entire realm of politics, including:
  • The political life of citizens
  • Political behavior and ideas
  • The government structure they seek and the roles it performs
• Uses methods like:
  • Description
  • Explanation
  • Investigation
• Political theory also examines politics in relation to social, economic, psychological, ecological, and moral dimensions.
• It is both prescriptive (what should be) and explanatory (what is).
• It aims to create a good state in a good society by building strong institutions, procedures, and structures.
• It tries to:
  • Explain why political events occur
  • Evaluate political actions
  • Predict future political developments

Nature of Political Theory

• Many theorists have explained its nature:
  • David Held: Political theory is a network of concepts related to political life, involving assumptions about government, state, society, and human political capabilities.
  • Andrew Hacker: Describes it as a blend of a search for principles of good governance and understanding political reality.
  • Norman Barry: Calls it an eclectic subject borrowing from various disciplines without a single method or body of knowledge.
• Political theory is:
  • Not entirely history, but uses historical context.
  • Not entirely philosophy, but includes values and morality.
  • Not entirely science, but adopts rational and objective methods.

Political Theory as History

• Advocated by George Sabine who saw political theory as deeply rooted in historical context.
• Believes that:
  • Political theory without history is like a structure without a base.
  • Understanding political thought requires understanding the time and place in which it was produced.
  • Example: Plato’s communism is different from Marx’s communism, and one can only understand both by exploring their respective historical backgrounds.
• Helps to:
  • Preserve meaningful ideas
  • Eliminate outdated concepts
  • Link past traditions with present and future ideas

Political Theory as Philosophy

• Supported by Leo Strauss who viewed philosophy as a quest for wisdom.
• Political theory here is:
  • An abstract study of values, norms, and morality.
  • Not just about knowing political facts, but evaluating their moral implications.
• Philosophy asks:
  • Why things exist
  • What makes an action good or bad
• Evaluation is key to understanding political ideas—thus philosophy enhances political theory by connecting it to moral reasoning.

Political Theory as Science

• Advocated by thinkers like Arthur Bentley, George Catlin, David Easton, and Robert Dahl.
• Emphasizes that:
  • Not all science is political theory, and not all political theory is scientific.
  • Unlike physics or chemistry, political theory lacks universal laws, fixed cause-effect relationships, or laboratories.
• However, political theory can still be called a science because:
  • It uses observable and testable concepts.
  • It follows rational and analytical methods.
  • It aims to produce objective and neutral knowledge.
• Referred to as a social science due to:
  • Its use of methodology, empirical research, and theoretical frameworks.
  • Aristotle’s description of it as a science based on study, observation, and reason.
• The role of science in political theory should be limited to:
  • Understanding political events
  • Balancing facts and values
  • Using both research and theory for valid conclusions

Significance of Political Theory

Control of Social Life

• Political theory provides scientific analysis of political life to understand and solve social problems.
• Enables:
  • Identification of causes of conflict and violence
  • Finding ways to prevent such crises
  • Promoting development by utilizing human resources
• Guides societies in resolving instability and social issues

Social Criticism and Reconstruction

• Political philosophy is concerned with right and wrong, good and evil.
• Helps people:
  • Critically evaluate the flaws in their society
  • Envision a better society
• Great thinkers like Plato, Aristotle, Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, Marx, and Mill have contributed ideas to build ideal societies

Clarification of Concepts

• Political philosophy clarifies complex ideas such as:
  • Authority
  • Liberty
  • Justice
  • Equality
  • Democracy
• Clarification prevents:
  • Misuse of terms
  • Manipulation of public opinion
  • Justification of authoritarian regimes (e.g. Mussolini in Italy)

Encouragement to Mutual Respect and Toleration

• Political theory promotes:
  • Dignified debates between differing viewpoints
  • Understanding and respecting others’ opinions
• The tradition encourages:
  • Dialogue over conflict
  • Discovering truth through rational persuasion
  • Avoiding emotional manipulation or ideological extremism

Concept of Political Theory: Approaches

The approaches to political theory represent different ways of studying political phenomena. These approaches are broadly classified into Traditional and Modern categories, each with its own focus, methods, and objectives.

Traditional Approaches

• These are value-based approaches that emphasize ethical, normative, and philosophical dimensions over empirical facts.
• Traditional thinkers believed that the study of politics should not be purely scientific because values and facts are deeply interrelated.
• Focused on institutions, history, and legal aspects to evaluate the right and wrong in political society.

Philosophical Approach

• Oldest approach in political science, tracing back to Greek philosophers like Plato and Aristotle.
• Leo Strauss emphasized the quest for wisdom and a good political order.
• Vernon Van Dyke considered it an effort to clarify the goals and means in studying politics.
• Focuses on:
  • Judging right or wrong
  • Evolving ethical standards
  • Understanding ideals of state, citizenship, rights, and duties
• Believes that values cannot be separated from politics, making it an idealistic and normative study.

Institutional Approach

• Primarily concerned with the formal structures of government such as:
  • Legislature
  • Executive
  • Judiciary
  • Political parties
  • Interest groups
• Adopted by both ancient and modern thinkers, such as Aristotle, James Bryce, Bentley, and Harold Laski.
• Focuses on how institutions shape political behavior and decisions.

Legal Approach

• Emphasizes laws, justice, and the legal framework within which politics operates.
• Focus on:
  • Legal institutions
  • Judiciary independence
  • Legal processes and justice systems
• Supported by thinkers like Cicero, Hobbes, Bentham, John Austin, and Dicey.

Historical Approach

• Studies the historical context of political ideas, systems, and institutions.
• Believes that every political idea must be understood in its historical time and place.
• Supported by Machiavelli, Sabine, and Dunning.
• Argues that:
  • The past provides insights into present and future political developments.
  • Political events occur in chronological order, helping scholars anticipate future trends.
• Critics argue that this approach may fail to understand past ideas using modern perspectives.

Characteristics of Traditional Approaches

• Normative in nature, with strong emphasis on values and ideals.
• Focused on institutions and formal structures rather than people’s behavior.
• Made limited effort to connect theory with research.
• Argued that politics cannot be studied scientifically because of the inseparability of facts and values.

Modern Approaches

• Emerged in response to the limitations of traditional approaches.
• Seek to make political science more scientific, empirical, and pragmatic.
• Emphasize fact-based analysis and focus on real-world political behavior.
• Introduced by new-age thinkers who wanted more relevance and objectivity in political studies.

Behavioural Approach

• Focuses on the behavior of individuals in political situations rather than institutions.
• Promoted by thinkers like David Easton, Robert Dahl, E.M. Kirkpatrick, and Heinz Eulau.
• Views regular patterns in political behavior as key to making generalizations and predictions.
• David Easton identified major features:
  • Regularities: Common patterns in behavior can help form theories and predictions.
  • Techniques: Use of research tools like surveys and models for verification.
  • Quantification: Measured data to analyze political behavior.
  • Values: Calls for separation of facts and values to maintain objectivity.
  • Systematization: Theory and research must go hand-in-hand.
  • Pure Science: Aim to develop political science as a verifiable discipline.
  • Integration: Believes political science should interact with other social sciences.
• Benefits:
  • Makes political science relevant to daily life
  • Helps in predicting political events
  • Promotes scientific methods in analysis
• Criticisms:
  • Overemphasis on being too scientific
  • Difficulty in studying human behavior accurately
  • Political events often lack clear cause-effect relationships

Post-Behavioural Approach

• Emerged in the mid-1960s as a response to the limitations of behaviouralism, especially its lack of concern for real-world problems.
• Focused on relevance and action, emphasizing that political science must be practical and socially useful.
• Advocated the need to address prevailing social and political problems rather than merely observing behavior.

System Approach

• Developed by David Easton.
• Views the political system as a part of a larger environment.
• Describes a cyclical process of inputs, outputs, and feedback:
  • Inputs: Demands and support from society (e.g. public demand for reservation in jobs).
  • Conversion: Government processes the inputs to formulate policies, rules, and laws.
  • Outputs: These decisions are implemented back into society.
  • Feedback: Society reacts, creating new inputs, continuing the cycle.
• Emphasizes the interconnectedness of political institutions and society.

Structural Functional Approach

• Considers society as a system of interrelated parts, each with distinct roles.
• An outgrowth of system analysis, emphasizing structures and their functions.
• Developed by Gabriel Almond, who outlined:
  • Input functions: Political socialization, interest articulation, interest aggregation, and communication.
  • Output functions: Rule-making, rule-application, and rule-adjudication.
• Almond highlighted three main characteristics of political systems:
  • Comprehensiveness
  • Interdependence
  • Defined boundaries

Communication Theory Approach

• Developed by Robert Weiner and advanced by Karl Deutsch.
• Treats the political system as a network of communication that is self-regulating.
• Emphasizes how information flows within a system influence decisions.
• Government is seen as a decision-making system dependent on:
  • Lead
  • Lag
  • Gain
  • Load
• Focuses on the importance of feedback mechanisms in policy-making and governance.

Decision-Making Approach

• Explores how decisions are made and who influences them.
• Focuses on the psychological and social aspects of decision-making.
• Key contributors: Richard Snyder and Charles Lindblom.
• Studies the individuals involved in political decisions, their motivations, and external influences.

Types of Approaches: Empirical vs Normative

• Empirical Approach:
  • Concerned with what is.
  • Uses observation, hypotheses, and testing.
  • Produces results that can be measured and verified.
• Normative Approach:
  • Concerned with what ought to be.
  • Focuses on justice, rights, equality, and values.
  • Uses philosophical reasoning and deductive methods.
  • Found in the works of Plato, Hobbes, Locke, Hegel, and Bentham.
• Both approaches are vital: one provides data and analysis, while the other offers moral judgment and guidance.

Marxian Approach

• Fundamentally different from both traditional and modern approaches.
• Based on the ideas of Karl Marx, as seen in ‘Communist Manifesto’ and ‘Das Kapital’.
• Offers a theory of social change, a scientific philosophy, and a sociological analysis of politics.
• Believes that:
  • Politics is shaped by economic conditions.
  • Material base determines the ideological superstructure.
  • Individuals are social beings first, political beings second.
• Rejects liberal and formal approaches, arguing that they ignore the class-based nature of society.

Conclusion

Political theory provides a comprehensive framework to understand, analyze, and improve political life. It encompasses everything from basic political ideas to complex institutional functions, spanning both normative values and empirical analysis. By studying political theory, one can critically evaluate political institutions, clarify essential concepts like liberty and justice, and become an informed and responsible citizen. The variety of approaches—from philosophical to behavioural to Marxian—reflect the depth and diversity of political thought. Ultimately, political theory helps build better governments and more just societies by offering tools for both critical reflection and practical action.

---

1. How does the evolution of political theory from traditional to modern approaches reflect the changing nature of political analysis?
2. Discuss the role of behavioural and post-behavioural approaches in making political science a more practical and socially relevant discipline.
3. Examine the contribution of political philosophy in clarifying key political concepts and shaping democratic political thought.